Full Plate by Abbie Attwood
The Full Plate Podcast with Abbie Attwood, MS
Is Diet Culture a Cult? Beauty, Patriarchy, and the Worship of Thinness with Paula Atkinson
0:00
-1:02:53

Is Diet Culture a Cult? Beauty, Patriarchy, and the Worship of Thinness with Paula Atkinson

Why we learned to distrust our bodies, how thinness became a measure of worth, and why it's so hard to break free.

Hi! Today is Election Day if you’re in the U.S. So please vote, then come listen to this beautiful, funny, rage-inducing (the right kind of rage!) conversation about why diet culture has always been embedded in politics and the safety of our bodies.


Today’s conversation has been a long time coming. Paula and I were supposed to meet earlier this year, and then I had an emergency appendectomy. We rescheduled…and then I had a heart attack from a spontaneous tear in my coronary artery. So apparently the universe had some very specific opinions about when we were allowed to talk.

It’s been a year, my friends. Anyone else riding the 2026 struggle bus!? I know there is some softness coming our way.

Anyway, we finally made it happen, and I’m so glad we did.

Paula Atkinson is a psychotherapist and Licensed Independent Clinical Social Worker who has spent decades working with people around trauma, disordered eating, body image, internalized weight stigma, anxiety, grief, and relationships. For ten years, she was also a professor of Weight & Society at George Washington University, where she taught about our culture’s obsession with thinness, the history and politics of body ideals, and the oppression of larger bodies.

Her background takes us into a conversation that gets very big, very quickly.
(my favorite kind of conversation!)

Today’s episode is free for everyone. Full Plate is made possible by paid subscribers. To receive bonus posts and support the pod, consider upgrading to paid. It really means the world, so, thank you!

Paula shares her experience growing up in a fat body, developing an eating disorder, and eventually coming to understand thinness as a kind of cult. One that teaches us to distrust our bodies, override our needs, and spend our lives chasing an ever-moving promise of belonging, desirability, purity, and superiority.

We talk about patriarchy, white supremacy, capitalism, and the history of beauty standards—including how women’s attractiveness became tied to their survival, and why the bodies we’re taught to desire are never separate from the culture and politics around us.

We also get into GLP-1s, starvation, and why body hatred makes a lot more sense when we stop locating the problem inside individual bodies.

And, because I know these conversations can get big and abstract, we bring it all back down to earth.

Because what do you actually do tomorrow morning when you know the body hierarchy is bullshit…and then you look in the mirror and hate what you see?

Paula has an answer for that, too. It involves seething feminist rage. So, obviously, I loved this conversation.

Listen for more on:

  • Paula’s experience growing up in a fat body, developing an eating disorder, and discovering how differently people treated her when her body became smaller

  • Why Paula thinks of thinness as a cult, and what makes its promises so difficult to walk away from

  • The relationship between beauty, patriarchy, white supremacy, and the policing of bodies

  • How attractiveness became tied to women’s survival, and why beauty standards shift alongside social and political power

  • Thinness as a moral hierarchy, and the promises of purity, superiority, and belonging

  • GLP-1s, starvation, and the normalization of suppressing our bodies’ most basic needs

  • Why understanding body hatred as a systemic issue can change the way we approach recovery

  • The grief of letting go of the promises attached to thinness, even when we know they aren’t real

  • What to do when you know the body hierarchy is bullshit but still struggle with your own body (hint: seething feminist rage)

Find more about Paula here. Follow her on Instagram here.
And if you’re not following Full Plate on Instagram, make sure to do that here!


I’d love to hear from you on this one.

- What's one belief about beauty or thinness that you once accepted as truth, but now see very differently?

- Has learning more about the history and politics of beauty changed how you think about your own body?

Leave a comment

Share

Please take a moment to hit the little heart button on this post if you enjoyed it! It helps others find the pod (ahhh, algorithms…). Thank you!

Discussion about this episode

User's avatar

Ready for more?